When it comes to employment verification in the United States, completing Form I-9 correctly is critical. This form serves as the initial step to ensure employees are legally authorized to work in the country. However, even with the best intentions, many applicants and employers face rejection due to several common mistakes. This comprehensive guide will walk you through the reasons your I-9 paperwork might be rejected, how to avoid these pitfalls, and steps to rectify any issues.
Common Reasons for I-9 Rejections
Incorrect or Incomplete Information: The most common issue encountered is providing incorrect or incomplete information on the Form I-9.
- Missing Signature: Both the employee and the employer must sign the form. An absence of either signature invalidates the document.
- Incorrect Date: Ensure dates are filled correctly, especially the date of hire.
- Blank Fields: If a field does not apply, use "N/A" rather than leaving it blank.
Improper Documentation: Employees must provide acceptable documents for verification. Issues arise when:
- Documents provided do not meet the USCIS standards for proving identity and employment authorization.
- Expired documents are submitted.
- Copies are used when originals are required.
Improper Notarization: Although not required for Form I-9, some employers mistakenly have the form notarized, leading to confusion and potential rejection.
Steps to Avoid I-9 Rejections
1. Understand the Requirements
- Thoroughly read the instructions provided with Form I-9.
- Keep updated with the latest list of acceptable documents for verification.
- Use official USCIS guidance to ensure all procedures are correctly followed.
2. Proper Document Handling
- Ensure documents are current; do not accept expired documents.
- Documents must be originals or certified copies by the issuing authority.
- Check the list of acceptable documents to ensure what is presented complies with the requirements.
3. Timely Completion
Form I-9 must be completed within the first three business days of employment. Here’s a breakdown:
- Day 1: Employee completes Section 1.
- Day 2-3: Employer verifies documents and completes Section 2.
4. Correct Filing and Storage
Employers must retain completed I-9 forms for a specific period, adhering to the following:
- Physical copies should be kept securely.
- Electronic records must follow specific electronic I-9 rules.
- Avoid storing the forms in personal files or in areas accessible by unauthorized personnel.
What to Do If Your I-9 Form is Rejected
Re-examine and Correct
If the USCIS or your employer returns your Form I-9 due to errors:
- Review the issues noted by the reviewer.
- Correct the errors, resubmit, or provide the missing information as soon as possible.
- Ensure all parties sign and date any amendments or updates to the form.
💡 Note: If significant corrections are needed, consider creating a new Form I-9 instead of amending the existing one.
Documentation for Corrections
- Keep a record of all communications and corrections made to the Form I-9.
- Notate any changes on the form itself with the date and initials of the person making the correction.
- If a new form is created, attach it to the old one with a note explaining the situation.
Rejections can be a learning opportunity. Here are key takeaways to improve future I-9 submissions:
- Accuracy is crucial; double-check all entered data.
- Ensure timely completion to avoid unnecessary delays or penalties.
- Stay informed about current documentation requirements and updates to the form.
- Employers should provide training for staff involved in the I-9 process to minimize errors.
This journey through the common pitfalls and necessary steps to ensure your I-9 paperwork is in order highlights the importance of diligence in this process. While the task might seem daunting, following these guidelines not only helps in getting your paperwork accepted but also ensures compliance with legal requirements, safeguarding both your employment and your employer's business. Whether you are an employee or an employer, understanding and implementing these steps will make Form I-9 verification a smooth part of onboarding, setting the foundation for a successful work relationship.
Can I fill out the I-9 form online?
+
Yes, you can complete Form I-9 online. Employers can use electronic I-9 systems, provided they adhere to specific electronic signature and recordkeeping requirements as outlined by USCIS.
What should I do if I lost my I-9?
+
If an employee loses their I-9 form, both the employee and employer need to complete a new Form I-9 following the original verification process. The employer should securely store the new form and attach a note to explain the circumstances.
How long must an employer keep I-9 forms?
+
Employers are required to retain Form I-9 for three years after the date of hire or one year after the date employment ends, whichever is later.
